Nutrition

Why Your PCOS Lab Results Look Normal—But You Still Feel Awful

by
Dr. Nina Ross, ND Ph.D
Certified Naturopathic Doctor
February 20, 2025

Living with PCOS can feel like being trapped in a maze where all signs point to "normal," yet your body is screaming otherwise. As a holistic practitioner specializing in women's hormonal health, I've seen countless patients struggle with this frustrating disconnect between their lab results and lived experience.

The Hidden Flaws in Standard PCOS Lab Testing

The story of "normal" lab ranges is more complex than most people realize. These ranges aren't universal truths—they're statistical averages based on specific populations, often excluding the beautiful diversity of human bodies and experiences.

The Problem with Reference Ranges

Traditional lab ranges were primarily established using data from white male participants, creating a significant blind spot in women's health care. When we apply these one-size-fits-all ranges to diverse populations, we miss crucial nuances that could impact diagnosis and treatment.

For example, what's considered a "normal" testosterone level might not account for the natural variations in women from different ethnic backgrounds. This oversight can lead to delayed diagnoses and unnecessary suffering.

Beyond the Basics: Often-Overlooked Markers

Standard PCOS testing typically focuses on androgens and reproductive hormones, but this narrow view misses critical pieces of the puzzle:

  • Vitamin D: A crucial hormone that affects insulin sensitivity and ovulation
  • Thyroid Function: Beyond just TSH, looking at free T3, free T4, and thyroid antibodies
  • Insulin Resistance: Fasting insulin and glucose curves tell a more complete story than A1C alone

Melanin's Impact on Lab Interpretation: What Doctors Miss

One of the most overlooked aspects of lab interpretation is how melanin affects various biomarkers. This oversight particularly impacts Black and Brown women seeking PCOS diagnosis and treatment.

The Vitamin D Dilemma

Melanated skin naturally requires more sun exposure to produce adequate Vitamin D. However, standard reference ranges don't account for this biological difference. What's considered "low normal" might actually be significantly deficient for women with more melanin.

Hormonal Variations in Melanated Bodies

Research shows that hormone metabolism can vary significantly based on genetic ancestry. For instance:

  • Cortisol patterns may differ in melanated individuals
  • Insulin sensitivity can vary across ethnic groups
  • Inflammatory markers might present differently

How to Advocate for the Right PCOS Tests

Knowledge is power, especially when navigating the healthcare system. Here's how to ensure you're getting the complete picture of your hormonal health:

Essential PCOS Lab Work Checklist:

  1. Comprehensive Hormone Panel
    • Total and Free Testosterone
    • DHEA-S
    • Androstenedione
    • Sex Hormone Binding Globulin (SHBG)
  2. Metabolic Health Markers
    • Fasting Insulin
    • Glucose Tolerance Test
    • HbA1C
    • Complete Lipid Panel
  3. Thyroid Function
    • TSH, Free T3, Free T4
    • Thyroid Antibodies
  4. Nutrient Status
    • Vitamin D
    • Iron Studies
    • B12 and Folate

Having the Conversation with Your Healthcare Provider

When discussing expanded testing with your doctor, approach the conversation as a partnership. Share your symptoms, track your cycles, and come prepared with research supporting your concerns.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What blood tests should I ask for if I have PCOS? A: Beyond the basic hormone panel, request comprehensive metabolic, thyroid, and nutrient testing. The checklist above provides a detailed starting point for discussion with your healthcare provider.

Q: Why do my PCOS labs look normal but I still have symptoms? A: Standard ranges often don't capture optimal levels for individual health. Additionally, conventional testing might miss crucial markers that could explain your symptoms.

Q: How does melanin affect lab test results? A: Melanin can impact various biomarkers, particularly Vitamin D levels and hormone metabolism. This means standard reference ranges might not be appropriate for everyone.

Remember, your symptoms are valid, even when lab results say otherwise. Understanding these nuances empowers you to advocate for more comprehensive testing and personalized interpretation of your results.

Want to learn more about interpreting your PCOS lab results? Download our comprehensive PCOS Lab Interpretation Guide [Download Link] for a deeper dive into optimal ranges and what they mean for your health journey.

by
Dr. Nina Ross, ND Ph.D
Certified Naturopathic Doctor

What can Nina Ross Functional Medicine do for you?

Nina Ross Functional Medicine is here to give you holistic solutions that will lead to a new healthy you!

Featured Posts

Sign up for our weekly newsletter

Get more about health, tips & exclusive offers sent straight to your inbox

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.